Congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation in a patient with Down syndrome: a case report

Down syndrome (OMIM 190685) is caused by trisomy of all or a critical portion of chromosome 21 and can be associated with congenital cervical spine abnormalities, including atlantoaxial instability with or without os odontoideum, atlanto-occipital instability, and hypoplasia of the atlas [1‐3]. Herein, we report the first case of Down syndrome complicated by congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation, which demonstrated progressive myelopathy and was successfully treated surgically.

There are no reports describing congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation; most reported cases have been trauma-related [4‐6]. Down syndrome is frequently complicated by congenital craniovertebral anomalies, which include atlanto-occipital instability, atlantoaxial instability, hypoplasia of the atlas, C1 lateral mass morphometric anomaly, basilar invagination with occipitoatlantal assimilation, bifida anterior and/or posterior altantal arches, condylar hypoplasia, ossiculum terminale, and os odontoideum [1‐3, 7‐10]. However, the etiology of these congenital upper cervical anomalies found in Down syndrome remains unelucidated. Hence, the congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation in this case might have occurred as a part of various congenital cervical malformations in Down syndrome. Despite the high prevalence of these congenital anomalies in patients with Down syndrome, the majority of these cases are asymptomatic, with estimates of symptomatic disease ranging from 1 to 2% [7, 11‐13]. Among the previously reported congenital craniovertebral anomalies in Down syndrome, hypoplasia of the atlas and os odontoideum were concomitantly found in the present case. However, the systematic understanding of craniovertebral anomalies in Down syndrome remains a challenge.

The optimal treatment for this congenital atlanto-occipital condition will be the subject of future studies. In this case, preoperative dynamic radiography of the cervical spine revealed limited cephalocaudal motion of the atlanto-occipital joint; therefore, reduction of the atlanto-occipital dislocation was presumed to be technically demanding. Hence, we conducted an in situ fusion and decompression, which was motivated by the partial neurological recovery from external halo vest immobilization alone. Although the short-term clinical course was favorable in our case, long-term follow-up and accumulation of similar cases are essential for determining the optimal treatment for this condition.

Additionally, it remains to be determined whether surgery before the development of myelopathy is recommended in patients with congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation, because the prognosis or natural course of this congenital condition is completely unknown. Retrospectively, our case may have benefitted from prophylactic surgery, given the preoperative severe and rapid neurological deterioration. However, determining the significance of prophylactic surgery for this congenital condition may be premature as neurological impairment in this case may have been affected by concomitant os odontoideum, a well-known predictive factor for neurological deterioration and a proposed indicator for prophylactic surgery due to its high-grade instability [14‐17]. Nevertheless, because the natural course of the patients with congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation alone is completely unknown, presently, the optimal timing for surgery in these cases may be at the time of the development of myelopathy. In that respect, non-surgical management before the development of myelopathy in these cases can be another matter of debate. It is generally recognized that patients with biomechanically significant bony anomalies at the occipitoatlantal junction are a special high-risk group and should be studied carefully [18]. Furthermore, a recent consensus study regarding the management of pediatric cervical spinal disorders concluded that clinical follow-up but not routine cervical radiographs are recommended at least until skeletal maturity is attained in children with cervical spine disorders that do not have current instability [19]. Given these considerations, regular monitoring of the neurological status of patients with this congenital condition may be recommended because anteriorly dislocated occipital bone to atlas results in basilar invagination due to shortening and severe local kyphosis of the craniovertebral junction, which causes neurological impairment, as seen in this present case.

A bifurcated internal occipital crest, which is reported in approximately 3% of the normal population, was identified in this case [20]. Therefore, it is not a rare condition; however, no reports have detailed the process of occipito-cervical fusion in patients with this condition. The insertion of occipital screws into the internal occipital crest was crucial for securing occipital plate fixation; therefore, we separately placed the occipital plates bilaterally and successfully obtained solid bone fusion. Although it remains to be clarified whether bifurcated internal occipital crest can be accompanied by congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation, surgeons should be preoperatively aware of patient-specific anatomy, especially in patients with congenital anomalies.

In conclusion, we have reported the first case of Down syndrome complicated by congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation that demonstrated progressive myelopathy and was successfully treated surgically. Although this condition seems to be extremely rare, we provided detailed information about the clinical course, including surgical treatment for future cases with congenital atlanto-occipital dislocation. The accumulation of similar cases is essential to determine the prognosis or optimal treatment for this congenital condition.